September is one of my favourite reading months of the year. As of September 1st, I’m always ready for all the witchy books I can get my hands on, and this year was no different. I really enjoyed almost everything I read in September, and I managed to read most of my September hopefuls, plus one that I hadn’t planned on reading yet but that became available for me at my local library.
Below is a list of everything I read in September 2026:

1. Weyward by Emilia Hart: 4/5 stars
Weyward was a great fall read. It’s a historical fiction novel that follows three women: Altha, a woman in 1619 who has been accused of murdering a man and of being a witch; Violet, a sixteen-year-old in 1942 who loves nature and is stuck in her family’s estate during World War II; and Kate, a woman in 2019 who flees her abusive partner for the cottage she inherited from her great aunt. The stories of the three women are woven together throughout the novel.
I really enjoyed this novel. The way the stories of the three women intersect is powerful. It highlights that while the rights of women have improved over time, there are some serious issues that women faced in the 1600s that they still face today. Part of why I love books about witches so much is that they tend to incorporate themes of resilience and female power. These themes were very much present in Weyward.
I listened to Weyward on audio, and the audiobook has multiple narrators – one for each of the three main characters. I thought the audiobook narration was well done.

2. A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna: 3.5/5 stars
A few years ago, I read The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna, and it was a great cozy fall read. For that reason, I have been eager to read A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by the same author.
A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping is about a witch who lost most of her magic and was exiled from her guild. While running an inn with her great aunt, she discovers a spellbook that contains the secret to restoring her lost magic. For help unlocking the spellbook, she turns to a historian staying at the inn for help.
Overall, I’m happy I read this, but it didn’t live up to The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches for me. I didn’t connect with the characters to the same degree that I did in The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches, and I didn’t think the main character and her romantic interest had much chemistry. The novel also tried to tackle some big issues, but to me those aspects of the novel sometimes felt rushed. The novel is a cozy, feel-good book though, and overall I liked it.

3. The Witches of Cambridge by Alice Hoffman: 5/5 stars
The Witches of Cambridge was my most-anticipated book release this fall. It’s the first book in what will be a three-book series. The novel takes place in the 1950s in Cambridge, Massachusetts. It centers on two women, Ava and Lauren, who are recruited into a secret group of witches called the Lilith Society.
I loved The Witches of Cambridge. The main characters are strong, resilient witches. It’s also set at Radcliffe College, and I always associate the fall season with school. The plot was exciting. The novel focused on the empowerment of women and the importance of female friendships. Alice Hoffman’s writing was in her usual dream-like style that I’ve come to crave each fall.
I did have a couple of minor qualms with The Witches of Cambridge regarding repetition and some grammatical errors, but those didn’t stop the novel from being a 5-star read for me.
My more detailed review of The Witches of Cambridge can be found here.

4. Rewitched by Lucy Jane Wood: 2.5/5 stars
In Rewitched, Belle Blackthorn struggles to protect the bookstore she works at from her boss, who is jeopardizing the bookstore’s future. At the same time, she keeps her witchcraft a secret. When Belle turns 30, she risks losing her magic forever and has until the end of October to protect it.
I had high hopes for Rewitched, since the combination of witches and a bookstore seemed foolproof. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case. I listened to the audiobook and I liked the narrator, but the book itself never fully captured my interest. I think this novel would have been better marketed as a young adult novel, as I felt that the main character, while being charming and funny, lacked the maturity I would expect from a 30-year-old woman. The plot should have been fast-paced given all that happened, but I found that the novel dragged.
If it’s one you’ve been interested in, I’d still give it a chance since reading is so subjective. For me, though, I’ve decided not to continue on with the series.

5. The Museum of Extraordinary Things by Alice Hoffman: 4/5 stars
Since I love Alice Hoffman’s novels, one of my reading goals is to read all of her books. I had done some research and saw that The Museum of Extraordinary Things is a good one to read in the fall, so that’s why I read it this month.
The Museum of Extraordinary Things is a historical fiction novel about a woman whose father runs the Coney Island “Museum of Extraordinary Things,” at which she also works. The novel is also about a young photographer who photographs the streets of New York and is asked to find out what became of a young woman who mysteriously disappeared.
This novel got off to a slow start for me, but I was definitely invested by the end. I found the last third of the book particularly exciting. It was very well-written, and I especially loved Coralie and Maureen. While I had read that the novel is a good one to read in the fall, it can really be read any time of the year.

6. A Time of Witches by Madeline Martin: 4/5 stars
A Time of Witches was another one of my most anticipated book releases this fall. It became available at my local library sooner than I expected, so I jumped at the chance to read it this month.
A Time of Witches is a dual-timeline historical fiction novel. It is about a woman named Lilith living in Savannah who has a recurring nightmare involving being burned alive at the stake. She travels to a manor house in England where she learns about her legacy. If she can’t rewrite history, she will cease to exist. At the same time, the novel is about a woman named Sybil living in 1645 Suffolk who has been accused of being a witch, imprisoned, and tortured, and who fights to protect her younger sister.
I loved this book! Even though I was looking forward to reading this fall, it exceeded my expectations. It was faster paced than I expected it to be, and despite me having read other novels about witch trials, I learned a lot about the witch trials that occurred in 1645 Suffolk. I especially enjoyed the parts of the novel that were from Sybil’s perspective. It was heart-wrenching and infuriating to read about the injustices that women in that time faced. The chapters in this novel were short (I think the longest chapters were about 8 pages), which made it easy to fly through it.

7. The Wishing Game by Meg Shaffer: 4/5 stars
The Wishing Game had been on my radar for a while, and I was excited to finally read it this month.
The novel is about a teacher’s aide, Lucy, whose favourite author announces he has written a new book and is having a contest at his house on an island in which the winner will win the only copy of the book. Lucy is chosen as one of the contestants. A large part of Lucy’s motivation for competing is to finally have sufficient means to adopt one of her students, Christopher.
I went into the novel expecting it to be a fantasy version of The Hunger Games. Having now read it, I wouldn’t describe it that way. It was cozier than I expected, and the competitions involved riddles and word games. I found this element of the novel really engaging, as it made me try to solve the riddles as well and feel as if I was competing. All in all, it was a heartwarming story and it was one that was easy to absorb. I listened to The Wishing Game on audio and enjoyed the narration.

8. The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion, Volume 6 by Beth Brower: 5/5 stars
Since there were so many summer-themed novels I wanted to read this summer, I hadn’t read an Emma M. Lion novel since June, and I couldn’t wait anymore.
The Emma M. Lion series takes place in the 1880s and follows a witty young woman named Emma after she returns to live at Lapis Lazuli House in the very quirky fictional London neighbourhood of St. Crispian’s. Each novel is a collection of journal entries written by Emma over the course of one or two months.
I love the Emma M. Lion series. If I could only read one series for the rest of my life, it would probably be this one. The novels are well-written and funny, while also being touching. They also have a way of reminding me how important the little things are in life. Volume 6 was the first of the Emma M. Lion series that I listened to on audio, and it was such a treat. The narrator, Genevieve Gaunt, does a wonderful job and really brings all of the characters to life. Without giving any spoilers, I also loved the way Volume 6 ended.

9. The Crescent Moon Tearoom by Stacy Sivinski: 4/5 stars
The Crescent Moon Tearoom is about three sisters, Anne, Beatrix, and Violet, who read tea leaves at their teashop. A Council of Witches visits them and requires that the sisters complete a challenging task. The Council advises that if they are unsuccessful, the sisters will be forced to close their teashop. At the same time, a curse threatens to separate them. Since I love witchy books and this one seemed so cozy, I was eager to read it.
I really liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom. It had the cozy elements that I was after, and while it begins in the spring, I think it’s a great fall read. There were some moments that I thought were a bit repetitive, but I was curious throughout the entirety of the novel as to what would happen. The way the house itself acts as a character was a sweet addition.
There is a sequel to The Crescent Moon Tearoom called The Witching Moon Manor, and I liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom enough that I’ll be reading the sequel.









Leave a Reply