Carol-Anne Reads
Monthly Wrap-Up: What I Read in August 2026

It was another fun month of summer reading! I found myself rating a lot of books 3 stars, but there were also some books that I really enjoyed. I focused on reading summer-themed books in August, but now that it’s September, I’m in full fall reading mode.

Below is a list of everything I read in August 2026:

1. Natural Selection by Elin Hilderbrand: 4/5 stars

Natural Selection is a short story by Elin Hilderbrand, and it’s one of her few short stories that isn’t connected to one of her novels. It’s the story of a woman who is about to board a plane to the Galapagos Islands with her boyfriend, when he suddenly tells her he can’t come. She travels to the Galapagos Islands alone, all the while wondering what is going on with her boyfriend.

This was an entertaining read, and I was curious about where it was heading throughout the entire story.

2. Sandwich by Catherine Newman: 3/5 stars

I’d been curious about Catherine Newman’s Sandwich for some time, and was excited to read it. It follows a quirky family who travels to Cape Cod for a week every summer. It goes back and forth through time, mainly detailing the struggles of the family’s matriarch.

This was a quick read that was at times amusing and at times heartbreaking. While it was an interesting book, I found myself eager to move on by the end.

3. Beautiful Day by Elin Hilderbrand: 3/5 stars

Beautiful Day is about the families of a couple getting married on Nantucket and their various dramas and struggles. An element of the novel that I loved and found really creative was that the bride’s deceased mother has left her a notebook that acts as a guide for planning the wedding. Pages of the notebook are interwoven throughout the novel.

In typical Elin Hilderbrand fashion, the novel had me itching to take a trip to Nantucket. The lives of the family members were interesting and drama-filled. Elin Hilderbrand novels have quickly become ones I can be sure to enjoy, and this one was no different. However, it wasn’t one of my favourites of hers that I’ve read.

4. The God of the Woods by Liz Moore: 3/5 stars

The God of the Woods is a mystery about a girl who goes missing from a summer camp in the Adirondacks. The novel also delves into the mystery of that same girl’s brother’s disappearance years earlier.

I had seen mixed reviews about The God of the Woods, but I hadn’t read any mysteries yet this summer, so I was excited to read this one. Unfortunately, I was underwhelmed. The novel is well-written, but I found it slow. I kept waiting for it to gain steam, but for me, it never did. I’m a fan of other mystery novels that aren’t necessarily fast-paced (I found some of Ruth Ware’s novels to be a bit slower-paced, for example, but I still loved them). However, this one just didn’t capture my interest enough to overcompensate for the slow pace. For me, this was a very middle-of-the-road mystery, and I doubt it will stick with me.

The God of the Woods is being adapted into a Netflix series, and I’ll be curious to see how the pace of the show compares to the book.

5. 28 Summers by Elin HIlderbrand: 5/5 stars

28 Summers is about a man and woman who spend every Labour Day weekend together for over two decades at the woman’s Nantucket cottage. It follows their lives over the course of 28 years, together and apart.

This novel has become my favourite Elin Hilderbrand novel I’ve read, surpassing The Five-Star Weekend. It was intriguing, it was heartfelt, and it included twists I didn’t see coming. It also includes mention of some Winter Street characters, and I love when Elin Hilderbrand’s novels reference characters from her other novels. One unique aspect of the book that I loved was that every chapter began with a list of what we were thinking about in that year. From beginning to end, I loved this book.

6. The Wedding People by Alison Espach: 3/5 stars

The Wedding People is about a woman who travels to a hotel in Newport, Rhode Island, where she intends to end her life. When she arrives, she learns that every other guest of the hotel is there for a wedding.

I was eager to read this, in part because I knew how popular it was (it was even the 2024 Goodreads Choice for best fiction). I listened to this book on audio, and it wasn’t really until the last third of the book that I was invested. I thought that third of the book was excellent, but I couldn’t ignore that the first two-thirds dragged for me. There were valuable messages in the book, and I’m still glad that I read it, but the book didn’t live up to my expectations.

7. A Summer Affair by Elin Hilderbrand: 3/5 stars

A Summer Affair is about a woman, Claire, who agrees to co-chair the Nantucket Children Summer Gala and starts up an affair with the executive director of the charity. It’s from the perspectives of multiple characters, including Claire, her high school boyfriend, and her best friend. While the gala takes place in the summertime, the novel spans roughly a year on Nantucket.

This was a fun read. It doesn’t stand out as one of my favourite Elin Hilderbrand novels, but I did enjoy it. Nantucket didn’t play as central of a role as it does in many of Elin Hilderbrand’s novels, and I missed that. I listened to the audiobook, which was narrated by Isabel Keating, and I thought the narration was well done.

8. The Island by Elin Hilderbrand: 4/5 stars

The Island is about four women who spend a month at their summer home on the island of Tuckernuck. Chess and Tate are sisters, Birdie is their mother, and India is Birdie’s sister (and Chess and Tate’s aunt). The women have come to Tuckernuck to help Chess recover from calling off her wedding and her ex-fiance then dying tragically. Along the way, each of the women grapple with their own issues.

I really enjoyed this one. I loved that the novel took place on Tuckernuck, a small and remote island west of Nantucket Island. I knew very little about Tuckernuck before reading The Island, so it was interesting to learn about the unique setting.

I found all of the characters interesting, and I was rooting for all four of the women. As is often the case with an Elin Hilderbrand novel, I was curious about what would happen next. I never find her novels predictable. I felt invested in this novel early on, and that remained the case until the end.

9. Girl’s Girl by Sonia Feldman: 2/5 stars

Girl’s Girl by Sonia Feldman follows a teenage girl, Mina, and her two best friends over the course of one summer. When Mina and one of her best friends kiss, the dynamic between the three friends is threatened.

I was disappointed with this one. The writing felt clunky and unnecessarily complicated and there was very little plot. Despite the novel being quite short, I found a lot of it repetitive. It felt like it could have been cut down to a novella without many of the details being lost. Thank you to NetGalley and The Dial Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

10. The Shampoo Effect by Jenny Jackson: 4/5 stars

The Shampoo Effect is the second novel by Jenny Jackson, who also wrote Pineapple Street. It’s about a woman, Caroline, who travels to a coastal town in Massachusetts for a writing fellowship and falls in love with a local, Van. We get to know Van’s tight-knit circle of friends, who have all been friends since they were kids. Caroline’s boyfriend discovers that his ex-girlfriend, who is part of the friend group, is pregnant with his baby, causing issues for Caroline and, ultimately, the friend group.

I listened to this one on audio and really enjoyed it. Marin Ireland narrated, and she’s become one of my favourite audiobook narrators. The novel is from the perspective of not just Caroline, but also other members of the friend group. It covers a lot of issues, from nepotism to the struggles of motherhood to trying to fit in. The Shampoo Effect was a really fun read that was easy to binge. I enjoyed Pineapple Street, but I enjoyed The Shampoo Effect more!

11. One Golden Summer by Carley Fortune: 4/5 stars

My final summer read was One Golden Summer by Carley Fortune. In it, we return to Barry’s Bay, the setting of Every Summer After. While Every Summer After was centered around Percy Fraser and Sam Florek, One Golden Summer is about Alice Everly and Sam’s brother, Charlie Florek.

Alice returns to Barry’s Bay for the first time since she was seventeen. She goes there with her grandmother for the summer and creates a bucket list of things she wants to do while she’s there. Alice gets to know Charlie, who joins her in checking off bucket list items throughout the summer. They vow to just be friends and have a fun summer, but when Alice realizes she’s developing feelings for Charlie, she worries that she’ll end up hurt.

The way Carley Fortune describes the settings of her books makes you feel like you’re right there with the characters. It was fun to return to Barry’s Bay and get to know Charlie better than we did in Every Summer After. I liked that this one was set solely in the present, whereas Every Summer After alternated between the past and the present. While I really enjoyed Every Summer After, I enjoyed One Golden Summer even more.

If you haven’t read Every Summer After, I would recommend reading it before reading One Golden Summer to avoid spoilers.

Leave a Reply

I’m Carol-Anne

Welcome to Carol-Anne Reads! This blog is all about books – the ones I’m reading, the ones I’ve read, and the ones I’m excited to pick up next. You’ll also find book news, seasonal book recommendations, book merchandise, author spotlights, and my reading tips. Whether you’re looking for your next favourite read or simply enjoy talking about books, I hope you’ll find something here to inspire your reading journey.

Let’s connect